Jump to content
outcast00096

Gotway Tesla vs Onewheel Plus

Recommended Posts

So... I own a Onewheel (og model). I'm part of the Onewheel owner group. There's a guy who wants to buy a Tesla but the Onewheelers... Well, they're Onewheelers. They don't have anything nice to say about anything that is not a OneWheel. They mostly see us as nerds and put down anything that is a different rideable. Anyway, here's a comment that got me going.

I'm not impressed...
Where does this 37mph figure come from? The specs say 40km/h which is roughly 24mph, I've gone that fast on my onewheel.
Increased range 60km (roughly 36 miles) and increased charge time of 5 hours, that's vs the 6 - 8 mile range I get, and 30 minutes tops on my charge time. 

I'm sticking with the onewheel, I definitely prefer the board sport posture vs the unicycle posture.

So, I ran the numbers and thought I'd put it here for fun, for posterity, and just to get other people's thoughts.

 

Onewheel Plus vs Gotway Tesla Stats -

 

36 miles divided by 8 equals 4.5 charges (OW+). 

4.5 x 30 minutes. 135 minutes charging. (Supposed to be 20 minute charging time but dude quoted that so I went with that anyway).

 

Extra 2 hours of traveling.

 

24 mph for 36 miles - 1.5 hours traveling. 

 

Onewheel total time - 3.5 hours. 

 

Tesla - 1.5 hours.

 

If Tesla has quick charger - 2 hour to 80%

 

80% of 36 miles. 28.8 miles

 

28.8 / 8 (guy quoted 8 for OW+) = 3.6 charges (Note: 8 miles on a OW charge is not unheard of but its not common)

 

3.6 x 20 mins (for giggles and I've always gotten 20 minute charges) 72 minutes charge - 1 hour and 12 minutes

 

24/mph for 28 miles - 1.167 hours

 

Onewheel wins back half (if charge time is 20 and not 30 min)

 

Figures do not include "limp" mode or reduced speeds for both models. The Tesla would not reach limp mode as quickly as the OneWheel because of larger battery. Assume  20% battery allows 10 to 12 mph on both models. 

 

OneWheel reaches 20% battery every 6.5 miles if 8 miles per charge. 

 

Tesla reaches limp mode (assuming it limps at 20%) when it has 7.6 miles left of 36.

 

Does not factor in that Tesla can reach speeds of 30 mph and higher.

 

Does not factor in hills or downhills.

 

Reliability is about the same on both machines. (Nosedives are common with OneWheels but they are usually due to user errors such as trying to go 24 mph for long distances.) <-- edit forgot the ending )

 

 

 

Edited by outcast00096
  • Upvote 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Charging time is really the least important factor I could think of. It hasn't even anything to do with the device itself, but with the battery and the delivered charger, which can be replaced rather easily.

  • Like 1
  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 11/20/2017 at 7:15 AM, meepmeepmayer said:

I don't think they're comparable. Riding style and usage and everything. Onewheels are like offroad/bumpyness-capable specialty skateboards, EUCs are actually useful general-purpose transportation tools and far better at this as we all know, those people are just jealous.:efef015fe0: I don't even care about stats - different ergonomics, different vehicles, different usages.

Let them have their "Onewheeler!" identities and their fun, we are beyond such requirements, EUCs are practical AND fun enough on their own.

(What other answer did you expect here?:efee612b4b:)

I want one but not as a skateboard but as a slightly (slightly!) different take on the EUC. Couldn't you convert any EUC into a One-wheel by simply placing a board over the foot pads? I doubt changing foot positions to mount would be difficult for any experienced Wheeler.

After observing one in real life for the first time yesterday, I do not think the One-wheel is suitable for any off-road. At all. Zilch. It's OK for doing downhill trails and and leveled fields but the chiseled front precludes going up steep hills and objects we can bunny hop just enough for our EUCs to catch and claw up.

I would love to see Gotway or KS to do a One-wheel done right, with great range, speed, a much better entry angle, and trolley able.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm a lifelong skateboarder and the one wheel was never interesting to me. Slow and no range and not a skateboard. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

He must have been really inexperienced OneWheel rider. 

The short answer is no. You could not put a board over the foot plates to make a OneWheel. You lean forward on the OneWheel to go forward. On an EUC you also lean forward to go. The difference is the foot placement. The toes point forward on an EUC and they point to the side on a OneWheel. If you switched stance to be in skateboard stance then you couldn't go forward. The only thing you could do is go left or right. You might be able to go diagonally forward or back but not true forward or backward because the EUC footplates were meant to be used with toes forward and not to the side.

If you're talking about standing EUC style on OneWheel then you're riding the SoloWheel Iota or the Sherpa (which is awesome, I want one, it looks like a cross between the onewheel and an EUC). However, you're not a OneWheel anymore, you're an EUC again.

Future Motion has done a great job with the OneWheel except for the starting and stopping. The detection of feet is sometimes very... Well, wonky at times.

Off-roading. OneWheels are for off-roading. Just watch the video below. These are v1 onewheels.

 

 

Edited by outcast00096
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
33 minutes ago, outcast00096 said:

He must have been really inexperienced OneWheel rider. 

The short answer is no. You could not put a board over the foot plates to make a OneWheel. You lean forward on the OneWheel to go forward. On an EUC you also lean forward to go. The difference is the foot placement. The toes point forward on an EUC and they point to the side on a OneWheel. If you switched stance to be in skateboard stance then you couldn't go forward. The only thing you could do is go left or right. You might be able to go diagonally forward or back but not true forward or backward because the EUC footplates were meant to be used with toes forward and not to the side.

If you're talking about standing EUC style on OneWheel then you're riding the SoloWheel Iota or the Sherpa (which is awesome, I want one, it looks like a cross between the onewheel and an EUC). However, you're not a OneWheel anymore, you're an EUC again.

Future Motion has done a great job with the OneWheel except for the starting and stopping. The detection of feet is sometimes very... Well, wonky at times.

Off-roading. OneWheels are for off-roading. Just watch the video below. These are v1 onewheels.

 

 

You seriously do not think placing a board around the EUC would not make it a One-wheel?

Let's be clear; a wooden/metal board going entirely around the EUC that basically extends the present boards around the EUC. Put another way; it'd be a 360 degree platform.

I mean, sure, mounting it you'd have to start off traditional EUC but then after you got going you'd have to make a little hop to get the feet in front and in back of the wheel.

Edited by LanghamP
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There have been people who put a board on an EUC and it did in fact behave like a one wheel. They're all using the same tech with the same kinda self balancing motors. They're not very different at all. I think this guy is a little confused. 

  • Like 2
  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not confused. Proves my point. Look at the way the pedals are moved. They are moved into Onewheel skateboard stance. It's modified. You couldn't just throw a board over a EUC and have it be an Onewheel. You'd have to modify it like this guy did. EUC pedals are toes forward. Onewheel pedals are side.

If you took your EUC outside right now as is and pushed left or right what would happen? Best case scenario, you'd be turning in circles. Worse case scenario you'd fall over. EUC's do not balance left and right, that's our job.

Edited by outcast00096

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, facepalm. Go outside and lean hard to your left on your EUC. Do not go forward just lean left. 

Edited by outcast00096

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why would someone put a skateboard on an EUC sideways? It's stupid to think that's what were talking about. We would point it forward, like a Onewheel. Are you even for real? 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

21 minutes ago, LanghamP said:

You seriously do not think placing a board around the EUC would not make it a One-wheel?

Let's be clear; a wooden/metal board going entirely around the EUC that basically extends the present boards around the EUC. Put another way; it'd be a 360 degree platform.

There's no mention of it here. There's just a mention of throwing a board over an EUC without other modifications. Not a knock. I'm just not a mind reader.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
33 minutes ago, outcast00096 said:

There's no mention of it here. There's just a mention of throwing a board over an EUC without other modifications. Not a knock. I'm just not a mind reader.

thinking about it, it would need less modifications as was done in the vid for going in conventional board direction as like you thought it were "throwing over" crosswise. I also wouldn't have thought the latter even for a second, but the OneWheel is by no means new to me or unique

 

Edited by Mono
  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This guy should have turned the wood over so not to have the feet trapped facing forward.

 

  • Like 1
  • Upvote 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's OK everyone. Relax. The new generation has everything turned 90 degrees from what our obsolete generation is used to. 

 

  • Like 2
  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

personally i think the one wheel just looks ridiculous its a big slab og wood with a big ugly wheel in the middle

the gotway tesla looks slick carbon on the sides and all 

IMO

but if you like the onewheel then get one or keep riding it if you have one but im going for the tesla with a lot better range speed and is as easy to carry as luggage 

i will buy a tesla over a onewheel everyday

Edited by Shad0z

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Onewheel (sp.) launched successfully on Kickstarter in January 2014. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Mmhmmm said:

Onewheel (sp.) launched successfully on Kickstarter in January 2014. 

@Mmhmmm - welcome to the forum - but I cannot see what point you are trying to make or are you trying to say OW being Kickstarter makes it better than the Tesla?

I.e. what exactly does your above statement have to do with this thread?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Keith, thanks for the welcome. My point is that the first Onewheel production units were delivered approximately four years ago.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×